When Judicial Campaigns Become Political Theater, Public Trust Pays the Price

By Donna Tryfman
A judicial election should be about something bigger than a campaign slogan, a political label, or a clever advertisement. It should be about whether a candidate understands the responsibility of sitting in judgment of another human being—and whether that candidate respects the public’s right to make an informed decision.
We should expect more from campaigns for judicial office.
Judges are entrusted with extraordinary power. Their decisions can determine whether someone goes to prison, whether a family is separated, whether a victim receives justice, and whether an individual’s constitutional rights are protected. The public must have confidence that those decisions will be based on the law and the evidence, not political pressure, personal loyalties, or public opinion.
The responsibility begins before a judge ever takes the bench.
Voters Deserve Facts, Not Spin
Judicial elections are difficult for voters. Most people do not have the time to examine decades of courtroom experience, evaluate a candidate’s legal judgment, or distinguish between a campaign’s characterization of a candidate and the underlying facts.
That’s why honesty in judicial campaigning is especially important.
When campaign messaging leaves out material context, uses labels in place of meaningful information, or encourages voters to draw conclusions that the facts do not support, it undermines the public’s ability to evaluate candidates fairly. When a campaign presents itself as principled while asking voters to accept contradictory or incomplete narratives, voters have every reason to ask questions.
These standards must apply to every candidate, including to my own campaign.
I welcome scrutiny. I believe voters should examine my record, ask difficult questions, and evaluate my qualifications against the responsibilities of the office. I expect the same scrutiny to be applied to every candidate seeking judicial authority.
One Misleading Claim Can Become an Entire False Narrative
Misinformation rarely stays confined to a single claim. One misleading statement can become the foundation for another, and then another, until repetition gives an inaccurate narrative the appearance of truth. A selective characterization becomes a talking point. The talking point gets repeated in campaign materials. Eventually, voters may encounter the same narrative so many times that they accept it without ever seeing the complete facts.
That is how public understanding becomes distorted—not necessarily through one dramatic falsehood, but through a succession of claims that reinforce one another.
In a judicial campaign, the consequences are especially serious. Voters often have limited information about judicial candidates and little time to investigate competing claims. They must be able to trust that campaign statements about experience, qualifications, and professional conduct are presented honestly and in context. Unfortunately, the competitive nature of campaigning brings out the worst in many.
When misleading narratives are repeated rather than corrected, the damage extends beyond the candidates. It diminishes the quality of public debate and risks eroding confidence in the judicial system itself.
A judicial campaign should not depend on repetition turning an assertion into accepted fact. It should depend on evidence, transparency, and a willingness to let voters examine the full record. Despite being competitive, judicial campaigns must be borne out of truth and verifiable data. Claims are easy to make, producing the evidence on which they lay, should not be difficult to find.
The judiciary cannot demand that litigants distinguish evidence from speculation while tolerating a campaign culture that blurs that very distinction. If we expect the public to respect the integrity of our courts, those seeking judicial office must demonstrate respect for the truth before they ever take the bench.
A Judicial Election Is Not a Partisan Contest
The office I am seeking is nonpartisan for a reason. A judge does not serve a political faction, an ideological movement, a donor, or an interest group. A judge serves the law and the public. Hence, I’ve embraced the “Everyone’s Judge” moniker early on and will embrace it throughout my tenure on the bench.
People appearing in court do not get to choose the judge who hears their case. They may disagree with that judge’s personal views. They may come from a different political party, a different religious tradition, or a different economic background. They may be unpopular or have been accused of terrible conduct. None of that relieves a judge of the obligation to treat them fairly.
The same principle should guide a judicial campaign. Political labels are not substitutes for a serious examination of experience, judgment, temperament, and integrity. Nor should voters be asked to confuse a campaign’s preferred image with a candidate’s actual record.
The question is not which candidate can adopt the most appealing label. The question is who understands the demands of the job and is prepared to carry them out fairly, consistently, and without fear or favor.
The Campaign Should Reflect the Office
I have spent more than three decades as a public defender. I have tried more than 100 jury trials, including complex homicide and other serious felony cases—all verifiable data. In contrast, throughout this campaign, many candidates have thrown out exaggerations of their numbers or experience, presumably to compete with their opponents. I have never done that because I have actually done the work and have the leadership experience I describe. My work has required me to defend constitutional protections, examine difficult evidence, make consequential decisions under pressure, and represent people whose circumstances or accusations might make them unpopular.
That experience has taught me that fairness cannot depend on whether we like someone, agree with them, or approve of their circumstances.
It has also taught me that the justice system depends on public confidence. Such confidence is difficult to earn and easy to damage.
I do not believe judicial candidates must agree on every issue or campaign in exactly the same way. Vigorous debate about qualifications and experience is appropriate. Criticism is appropriate. Voters should be free to question every candidate.
But there is a difference between making a case for oneself and creating an impression that the actual facts and data do not justify. There is a difference between explaining a record and relying on a label. And there is a difference between campaigning to earn public trust and treating a judicial election like any other political contest. Exaggerated experience or numbers may satisfy the immediate desire to be competitive, but it damages the dignity of the office sought.
When those distinctions disappear, the judiciary itself is cheapened.
The Standard Must Be Higher
I am running for judge because I believe the Constitution applies to everyone. That principle is not a campaign slogan to me. It is the foundation of the work I have done throughout my legal career and the standard I would bring to the bench.
I want every person who enters a courtroom to know that the judge will listen, follow the law, consider the evidence, and make a decision without fear or favor. This is what fairness requires. It is also what public confidence requires.
Voters deserve a clear account of each candidate’s experience and record. They deserve the opportunity to distinguish facts from rhetoric. And, they deserve candidates who recognize that the dignity of the judiciary matters more than the temporary advantages of a campaign. People remember.
The public’s trust in our courts is too important to sacrifice for a campaign tactic.
The judiciary is not a political prize. It is a public trust. The way we campaign for it should reflect that responsibility.

— Donna TryfmanCandidate for Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge, Office No. 131




Comments